Skip to content

Scene

A salt archive holds testimony about an old flood. It could help establish who was responsible for decisions about the damage. Even with the name removed, the voice may identify the witness.

Opening proposition

If the witness did not authorize publication of their voice, the archive should release only a summary that protects their identity.

Opening · Ali

↑ Upright · ↓ Reversed

CardWhat Ali says with the card

A1 · ↑ 15 The Missing Ledger
“The testimony could help document the decisions made after the flood.”

A2 · ↓ 10 The Borrowed Face
“Even with the name removed, someone who recognizes the voice could identify the witness.”

A3 · ↓ 11 The Second Mirror
“A public summary could change the story the settlement has told for years. Readers need a way to assess what it rests on.”

Example reply · Ayşe

Target · X Opening proposition

X → 24 Set the Measure

Move

24 Set the Measure
Let’s define what we mean by a summary that protects the witness’s identity.

Proposed outcome

Remove names, distinctive turns of speech, and details unique to the witness. The date of the decision could stay. Details of a shift they worked alone should be withheld.

Open question

Who should judge whether a detail could identify the witness?

The Salt Libraries · Cases